Pilar de La Horadada, Alicante vs Benahavís, Málaga — Investment Comparison

Side-by-side comparison of 131 new-build properties across both towns.

Overall Winner
Pilar de La Horadada, Alicante
Average investment score 50/100 vs 48/100
Metric
Pilar de La Horadada, Alicante
Benahavís, Málaga
Listings
97
34
Avg Price
€389,572
€2,295,508
Avg Gross Yield
6%
1.7%
Avg Discount
7.5%
5.2%
Avg Score
50/100
48/100

Analysis

When comparing Pilar de La Horadada, Alicante and Benahavís, Málaga as property investment destinations on Spain's coast, several key differences emerge. Pilar de La Horadada, Alicante is the more affordable option, with average new-build prices approximately €1,905,936 lower. This price advantage can make a significant difference for investors working within a fixed budget or seeking higher leverage.

In terms of rental income, Pilar de La Horadada, Alicante edges ahead with an average gross yield of 6%, while Benahavís, Málaga sits at 1.7%. The yield gap reflects differences in purchase prices relative to achievable rental rates in each area.

Overall, Pilar de La Horadada, Alicante takes the lead with an average investment score of 50/100, factoring in value, yield potential, location quality, developer track record, and market positioning. That said, both towns have compelling listings — the best strategy is to shortlist properties in each location and compare them on a deal-by-deal basis. Market conditions shift, and today's underdog can become tomorrow's hotspot.

Explore Each Town